Tired of all this political nonsense?

Sign up and get inspired everyday

Discourse Around Affirmative Action

affirmative action

Source: Pixabay

Affirmative action has been challenged since its introduction in the ’60s. Today, Students for Fair Admission are suing Harvard University for unfairly accepting students based on their race rather than merit.

They claim that White and Asian-Americans are being discriminated against in the applicant process due to their race. Is this the fall of Affirmative Action or something deeper?

Going back to the infancy of this policy, many argued that this policy excluded white students. This later included Asian-Americans. Time and time again, there are students who claim that they were declined from an Ivy League because they did not fit the quota.

Universities had a quota system until it was ruled unconstitutional in the ’70s. Therefore, a quota system is not in place at any U.S. University today.

Diversity still needs to be represented on college campuses. By being race-conscious, universities were still able to recognize diverse applicants while remaining constitutional.

They apply a holistic review to their applications. With a holistic review, race is one of many factors considered. Other factors include essay, GPA, extracurriculars, and more. However, Edward Blum, leader of Students for Fair Admission,  continually blames a student’s race, White and Asian-American, for being the main reasoning behind their rejection.

Many question Blum’s motives. Up until recent years, Blum has just begun speaking out for Asian-Americans students. The Harvard case is a prime example.

There are speculations that he is only using these students as pawns in his racist agenda. By using Asian-American students, he would also be benefitting white students. It comes down to if this is a civil rights or an individual issue.

The percentage of Asian-American admits is going up every year. White students remain the majority at Harvard. Every year, the applicant pools get more competitive.

This is not an issue of the system discriminating against a certain race such as White or Asian-American students, but an issue regarding how difficult it is to be accepted to a top university.  Is opposition truly fighting for the Asian-Americans and White students as a whole or for themselves to earn a spot at an Ivy League?

Because they holistically review applications, there are many factors to explain their denial. Race does not present a higher importance than any other. Students are accepted to these universities because they are well rounded in most of the factors considered.

A Black or Hispanic/Latino student does not take a place from a White or Asian-American student based solely on their race. If they were, why are they still two of the lowest represented races at Harvard?

If affirmative action is eliminated, we would see diversity among campuses across the country plummet. Diversity creates a campus that mirrors the world awaiting them beyond graduation.

Every admit deserves their position at their university. Universities celebrate student’s heritage and do wish for students to conceal parts of themselves in hopes of being accepted into their institution.

Affirmative action provides an opportunity for minority students to attend prestigious universities, especially first-generation students who were accepted on their own merit, not through a legacy program thanks to their parent. Though the system has its flaws, it provides a respectable foundation for diversity in universities.

By: Vivianna Shields



A young woman typing on a computer at an office

How These Entrepreneurs Built Successful Businesses From Nothing

Starting from scratch and being a successful entrepreneur is the dream of many. However, only a few succeed in fulfilling…

Muslim in America – Voices

Muslim in America – Voices

“Because of Bush and 9/11, I think people are scared to really understand what Islam is as a religion.” Bronx,…

Superficial Aspects Of Social Media

Superficial Aspects Of Social Media

“Pictures can tell a lot about an individual, but they do not tell the full story.” Brooklyn, NY Dating in…

Body Image – Voices

Body Image – Voices

“If you do not like your image, then change it to your liking but don’t change it so it can…

Body Image – Voices

Body Image – Voices

“Looking like a model doesn’t really matter in the grand scheme of things. As long as you have a good…

Body Image – Voices

Body Image – Voices

“Sometimes changing the narrative for yourself would be my advice for myself and for other people.” Albany, NY I love…


Meet Camila Chiriboga: Pioneer of Fashion for the Blind

The fashion industry is a major tool of power. Today, more so than ever, fashion is also being used as…


Girl Receives Massive Support on Twitter After Being Shamed For Her Figure At Church

Recently, a 19-year-old young woman named Jenna was given a hard time at a church in North Carolina for wearing…

Body Image – Voices

Body Image – Voices

“I would advise everyone to be themselves the best way they can.” Hempstead, NY I remember my freshman year of…